Best fishing near Old Bethpage

3 fishing spots · 3 ranked · updated 2026-06-22 · off-season

Explore the best fishing near Old Bethpage, New York — every spot ranked by our conditions-aware Snoflo score: live conditions first, then visitor reviews and logged trips. Click a pin on the map for the score and what's driving it.

Showing the top 3 of 3 fishing spots · best 15 shown on the map
B⛰
Bunnells Pond
#1 Bunnells Pond Fair
34.2 mi away
· Water 51°F · cold, sluggish· Clear water · 1 FNU· Low water · fish concentrated
Bunnells Pond in Bridgeport, Connecticut offers a variety of fish species to catch, including largemouth bass, bluegill, crappie, and catfish. Nearby activities include hiking…
Why 60: live conditions (fair)
60Solid
T⛰
The Gulf
#2 The Gulf Fair
37.2 mi away
· Water 51°F · cold, sluggish· Clear water · 1 FNU· Low water · fish concentrated
There is no Gulf fishing area in Connecticut as the state does not have access to the Gulf of Mexico. However, there are numerous fishing opportunities in Connecticut's Long…
Why 54: live conditions (fair)
54Solid
I⛰
Isinglass Reservoir
#3 Isinglass Reservoir
39.5 mi away
Isinglass Reservoir is a popular fishing area located in Portland, Connecticut. The reservoir is stocked with trout, including brown and rainbow trout, making it a great spot for…
Why 25: resort size & terrain
25Rated

Fishing near Old Bethpage

The Old Bethpage area has 3 fishing spots on Snoflo, ranked by live conditions, visitor reviews, and logged trips — so the best, closest options rise to the top.

How we rank the best fishing near Old Bethpage

How are these fishing spots ranked?

Each gets a daily Snoflo score blending live conditions, visitor review ratings, and logged trips. The order reflects what's best right now and re-ranks every day.

How often does it update?

Daily, as new conditions, reviews, and trips arrive — so "best right now" means right now.

What do the numbers on the map mean?

Each pin shows that spot's current Snoflo score; tap it for the breakdown and a link to the full report.

More fishing in New York

All New York fishing spots →