Best fishing near New Carlisle

7 fishing spots · 7 ranked · updated 2026-07-26 · off-season

Explore the best fishing near New Carlisle, Indiana — every spot ranked by our conditions-aware Snoflo score: live conditions first, then visitor reviews and logged trips. Click a pin on the map for the score and what's driving it.

Showing the top 7 of 7 fishing spots · best 15 shown on the map
N⛰
North Chain Lake
#1 North Chain Lake Good
5.7 mi away
· Nearby flows above normal· Air quality / smoke advisory· Patchy Smoke · 67°F
North Chain Lake in Indiana is a popular fishing spot for anglers due to its diverse range of fish species. The lake is home to largemouth bass, bluegill, crappie, and channel…
Why 75: species variety
75Top-rated
W⛰
Worster Lake
#2 Worster Lake Good
12.5 mi away
· Nearby flows above normal· Air quality / smoke advisory· Patchy Smoke · 67°F
Worster Lake is a popular fishing spot located in Northern Indiana. The lake is stocked with a variety of fish species, including largemouth bass, bluegill, crappie, and channel…
Why 75: species variety
75Top-rated
F⛰
Fishtrap Lake
#3 Fishtrap Lake Good
13.8 mi away
· Water 65°F · a bit cool· Partly Cloudy · 64°F · 5 mph wind
Fishtrap Lake is located in Pike County, Indiana, and is known for its excellent fishing opportunities. The lake is home to several fish species, including largemouth bass…
Why 75: species variety
75Top-rated
P⛰
Pine Lake
#4 Pine Lake Good
14.8 mi away
· Water 65°F · a bit cool· Partly Cloudy · 64°F · 5 mph wind
Pine Lake in Indiana offers a variety of fish species, including largemouth bass, bluegill, crappie, and channel catfish. Nearby activities include hiking, camping, and boating…
Why 75: species variety
75Top-rated
S⛰
South Chain Lake
#5 South Chain Lake Good
5.9 mi away
· Nearby flows above normal· Air quality / smoke advisory· Patchy Smoke · 67°F
South Chain Lake in Indiana is a great fishing destination for anglers. The lake is home to a variety of fish species including bluegill, crappie, largemouth bass, and catfish…
Why 63: species variety
63Solid
S⛰
Saint Mary's Lake
#6 Saint Mary's Lake Good
12.3 mi away
· Nearby flows above normal· Air quality / smoke advisory· Patchy Smoke · 67°F
Saint Mary's Lake fishing area is located in Indiana, USA. The lake is home to various fish species, including largemouth bass, bluegill, crappie, and catfish. Visitors can enjoy…
Why 63: species variety
63Solid
W⛰
Wharton Lake
#7 Wharton Lake Good
11.2 mi away
· Nearby flows above normal· Air quality / smoke advisory· Patchy Smoke · 67°F
Wharton Lake is a popular fishing area in Indiana, USA, particularly for bass, bluegill, and catfish. Nearby activities include hiking, camping, and boating. Fishing tips include…
Why 38: species variety
38Rated

Fishing near New Carlisle

The New Carlisle area has 7 fishing spots on Snoflo, ranked by live conditions, visitor reviews, and logged trips — so the best, closest options rise to the top.

How we rank the best fishing near New Carlisle

How are these fishing spots ranked?

Each gets a daily Snoflo score blending live conditions, visitor review ratings, and logged trips. The order reflects what's best right now and re-ranks every day.

How often does it update?

Daily, as new conditions, reviews, and trips arrive — so "best right now" means right now.

What do the numbers on the map mean?

Each pin shows that spot's current Snoflo score; tap it for the breakdown and a link to the full report.

More fishing in Indiana

All Indiana fishing spots →