Best trails near Middle Island

22 trails · 22 ranked · updated 2026-06-28 · off-season

Explore the best trails near Middle Island, New York — every spot ranked by our conditions-aware Snoflo score: live conditions first, then visitor reviews and logged trips. Click a pin on the map for the score and what's driving it.

Showing the top 15 of 22 trails · best 15 shown on the map
R⛰
Rocky Point Pine Barrens
#1 Rocky Point Pine Barrens
1.8 mi away
Why 78: intrinsic quality
78Top-rated
B⛰
Blue Horse Trail
#2 Blue Horse Trail
2.6 mi away
Why 60: intrinsic quality
60Solid
R⛰
Red Horse Trail East
#3 Red Horse Trail East
2.7 mi away
Why 59: intrinsic quality
59Solid
R⛰
Rocky Point Mountain Bike Trail
#4 Rocky Point Mountain Bike Trail
2.6 mi away
Why 58: intrinsic quality
58Solid
R⛰
Red Horse Trail West
#5 Red Horse Trail West
2.0 mi away
Why 57: intrinsic quality
57Solid
R⛰
Rocky Point Horse Red West
#6 Rocky Point Horse Red West
2.5 mi away
Why 57: intrinsic quality
57Solid
Y⛰
Yellow Connector
#7 Yellow Connector
1.3 mi away
Why 56: intrinsic quality
56Solid
Y⛰
Yellow Shortcut West 2
#8 Yellow Shortcut West 2
1.8 mi away
Why 56: intrinsic quality
56Solid
B⛰
Blue-Red Connector
#9 Blue-Red Connector
1.9 mi away
Why 56: intrinsic quality
56Solid
B⛰
Blue Horse Trail SE
#10 Blue Horse Trail SE
2.0 mi away
Why 56: intrinsic quality
56Solid
M⛰
Main Road Connector
#11 Main Road Connector
2.1 mi away
Why 56: intrinsic quality
56Solid
L⛰
Lust Garden Loop
#12 Lust Garden Loop
2.3 mi away
Why 56: intrinsic quality
56Solid
Y⛰
Yellow Shortcut West 1
#13 Yellow Shortcut West 1
2.3 mi away
Why 56: intrinsic quality
56Solid
Y⛰
Yellow Shortcut East
#14 Yellow Shortcut East
2.4 mi away
Why 56: intrinsic quality
56Solid
W⛰
Wood Road
#15 Wood Road
2.8 mi away
Why 56: intrinsic quality
56Solid

Trails near Middle Island

The Middle Island area has 22 trails on Snoflo, ranked by live conditions, visitor reviews, and logged trips — so the best, closest options rise to the top.

How we rank the best trails near Middle Island

How are these trails ranked?

Each gets a daily Snoflo score blending live conditions, visitor review ratings, and logged trips. The order reflects what's best right now and re-ranks every day.

How often does it update?

Daily, as new conditions, reviews, and trips arrive — so "best right now" means right now.

What do the numbers on the map mean?

Each pin shows that spot's current Snoflo score; tap it for the breakdown and a link to the full report.

More trails in New York

All New York trails →